Hello Fig,
The chances are that the carbon discs inside the control have broken away, the best thing to do is to get yourself a new foot control only, YDK is the favourite and they are cheap enough, only two wires to wire in and very easy, if you have a sewing machine shop nearby they should stock them or if you want to buy on line in the UK try www.sewingonline.co.uk/instructions , if you are in the US or other I don't have any sites for foot control spares.
Ken
drivewithken@blueyonder.co.uk, April 2008