You better start believing. It is possible and very common for 2, 3 or even all 4 simmerstats to fail. The ones they use now are useless and very unreliable. What you describe is a common symptom of a failed simmerstat. The heat stays on high. I am perplexed that you state you are an electrician but don't appear to understand how a simmerstat works. It does not adjust and change the voltage. It changes the heat by switching on & off. The lower the setting the longer it stays off and shorter time on & vice versa. Wiring must be ok if you are getting power to the element when you switch it on. Simple test is to put the simmerstat from the one good element in place of one faulty one. If that element now works properly then problem solved and go buy 3 new ones. Also, as Peccavi stated all 4 simmerstats will be wired the same (unless 1 is a dual temperature element) so compare the 4 switches and check that the wiring is all the same. You don't need wiring diagrams for that.
Lincoln Appliance NZ, April 2013