My gear is still in mint condition...the starter solenoid is not extening the gear to the flywheel gear. Or at least that is my interpretation of what is happening...I assume the gear should be in constant contact and there is a solenoid in the starter to extend the gear to flywheel during starting process. If it help the engine is a 17.5 hp ohc briggs and stratton model 31c707 type 0154 e1
Don, June 2007